Get AI summaries of any video or article — Sign up free
Extraterrestrial Superstorms thumbnail

Extraterrestrial Superstorms

PBS Space Time·
6 min read

Based on PBS Space Time's video on YouTube. If you like this content, support the original creators by watching, liking and subscribing to their content.

TL;DR

Gas giant storms are often anti-cyclonic, high-pressure vortices, unlike Earth’s typically cyclonic low-pressure hurricanes.

Briefing

Gas giants host storms that dwarf anything on Earth—planet-sized vortices driven by internal heat and atmospheric chemistry rather than ocean evaporation. The largest and most famous example, Jupiter’s Great Red Spot, can persist for centuries, with winds that remain strong even as the storm’s shape and size appear to change. Understanding why these anti-cyclonic systems last so long—and whether they are beginning to fade—has become a central goal for planetary science.

On Earth, hurricanes, cyclones, and typhoons share a common engine: warm, moisture-laden air rises, cools, and condenses, while precipitation and cooler air sink, sustaining a vertical convection cell. The storm’s rotation comes from the Coriolis force acting on air moving over a rotating planet, producing cyclonic rotation—clockwise in the Southern Hemisphere and counterclockwise in the Northern. Hurricanes weaken when they lose access to warm ocean water, because convection and moisture supply stall. Low-pressure cores tend to support longevity by drawing in moist air, while high-pressure cores push air outward, depleting moisture and shortening the storm’s life.

Gas giant storms follow a different rulebook. They are often anti-cyclonic, high-pressure systems, powered largely by the slow gravitational contraction of the planet rather than solar heating of a surface ocean. As Jupiter and other gas giants shrink over time, gravitational potential energy converts into heat. That heat drives convection: rising gas cools, and—unlike Earth’s relatively narrow condensation chemistry—gas giants span wide temperature and pressure ranges that allow many molecular species to condense. Phase changes release latent heat, lifting storms higher through the troposphere, which can extend roughly 100 miles into a gas giant’s interior. Strong storms can even breach into the stratosphere, warming upper layers; in Jupiter’s case, activity associated with the Great Red Spot warms the upper atmosphere to about 1,600 Kelvin.

The longevity puzzle remains unsolved, but several factors appear to help. The Great Red Spot likely benefits from a near-continuous internal heat supply, abundant condensable molecules, frequent “cannibalization” of smaller storms, and a surrounding environment shaped by jet streams moving in opposite directions at roughly 300–400 miles per hour. Even so, recent observations suggest the storm may be changing. Its size has shrunk dramatically since the 1800s—from about 37,000 kilometers across (roughly three Earths wide) to about 16,350 kilometers (about 1.3 Earths) as of April of this year. It is also becoming more circular, while wind speeds appear not to have dropped.

To probe the structure behind those changes, NASA’s Juno mission—launched in 2011—has been flying close to Jupiter, coming within about 3,400 kilometers of the cloud tops and ultimately designed to crash into them to protect potentially life-bearing moons like Europa. Juno carries eight instruments, including a radiometer, imaging spectrograph, magnetometer, and JunoCam. Every 53 days, it dips into Jupiter’s radiation belt and collects high-cadence imagery during a two-hour pole-to-pole transit, snapping pictures every 60 seconds to measure cloud heights and horizontal drift.

JunoCam images processed with help from citizen scientists have revealed new internal behavior within the Great Red Spot: more “storms within storms,” a shift from long streaks to smaller eddies, and a calm central region reminiscent of a hurricane’s eye. The emerging picture links increased turbulence—acting like friction that saps rotational energy—to the spot’s shrinking and circularization. With dozens more flybys still ahead, scientists are now working through a growing dataset to determine whether the Great Red Spot is merely evolving or truly entering a long decline.

Cornell Notes

Gas giant storms are not just scaled-up hurricanes; they’re typically anti-cyclonic, high-pressure systems powered by internal heat from planetary contraction. Jupiter’s Great Red Spot can last for centuries because it has a long-lived energy source, abundant condensable molecules, and a dynamic environment shaped by fast opposing jet streams. Recent measurements show the Great Red Spot has shrunk substantially since the 1800s and is becoming more circular, while winds may remain strong. Juno’s close flybys and high-cadence imaging are helping connect those changes to the storm’s internal structure, including a transition toward more turbulent flow. That turbulence could drain energy from the bulk rotation, offering a plausible mechanism for the spot’s evolution.

How do Earth hurricanes stay alive, and why do they weaken over land?

They run on convection powered by warm, moisture-rich ocean water. Warm air rises, cools, and condenses into clouds; precipitation and cooler air sink, sustaining a vertical convection cell. Moisture supply matters: the low-pressure core draws in wet air, which rises and rains out, replenishing the storm’s central region. Over land or cold water, the moisture and heat input drop, convection weakens, and the storm dies. Low-pressure cores support longevity by pulling in moist air, while high-pressure cores push air outward and deplete moisture, shortening storm life.

What makes gas giant storms fundamentally different from Earth storms?

Gas giant storms are often anti-cyclonic, high-pressure systems rather than cyclonic low-pressure systems. Their energy source is not solar-warmed ocean water but the planet’s slow gravitational contraction, which converts gravitational potential energy into heat. Convection still drives the storms, but the chemistry differs: gas giants span wide temperature/pressure ranges, so many molecular species can condense, releasing latent heat at multiple phase changes (gas→liquid→solid). This supports deep convection through the troposphere and can even reach the stratosphere.

Why can Jupiter’s Great Red Spot persist for centuries even though storms usually lose energy?

Multiple factors likely reinforce it: a near-continuous internal heat supply, abundant condensable molecules that keep condensation possible across a wide range of conditions, and interactions with smaller storms. The Great Red Spot also appears to be embedded between two jet streams moving in opposite directions at about 300–400 miles per hour, helping keep the vortex spun up. Still, its centuries-long stability is not fully understood, and recent changes suggest it may be evolving.

What evidence suggests the Great Red Spot is changing, and what might that mean?

Observations indicate shrinkage and shape change. In the 1800s it spanned about 37,000 kilometers (~three Earths wide), but by April it measured about 16,350 kilometers (~1.3 Earths). It is also becoming more circular. Importantly, wind speeds do not appear to have diminished proportionally, raising the question of whether the storm is transitioning in structure rather than simply weakening.

How is Juno helping scientists connect the Great Red Spot’s structure to its evolution?

Juno performs close flybys within about 3,400 kilometers of Jupiter’s cloud tops and uses eight instruments, including JunoCam for high-resolution imaging. Every 53 days it dips under Jupiter’s radiation belt and collects data during a two-hour pole-to-pole transit, taking pictures every 60 seconds. That cadence supports measuring cloud heights and horizontal drift (wind speeds). JunoCam images show internal complexity—“storms within storms”—and a transition from long streaks to smaller eddies, suggesting a shift from streamline flow to turbulence. Turbulence can act like friction, sapping energy from the bulk rotation and potentially contributing to shrinking and circularization.

Review Questions

  1. What roles do low-pressure vs high-pressure cores play in storm longevity, and how does moisture supply differ between them?
  2. Why does condensation chemistry on gas giants allow deeper, longer-lasting convection than on Earth?
  3. What specific internal flow changes seen by JunoCam could plausibly explain the Great Red Spot’s shrinking without a major drop in wind speed?

Key Points

  1. 1

    Gas giant storms are often anti-cyclonic, high-pressure vortices, unlike Earth’s typically cyclonic low-pressure hurricanes.

  2. 2

    Earth hurricanes are powered by convection driven by sun-warmed ocean water and sustained by a continuous moisture supply.

  3. 3

    The Coriolis force explains hurricane rotation on Earth, producing opposite spin directions in the two hemispheres.

  4. 4

    Gas giant storms draw energy mainly from planetary contraction, converting gravitational potential energy into heat that drives convection.

  5. 5

    Condensation on gas giants involves many molecular species across wide temperature and pressure ranges, releasing latent heat and supporting deep convection.

  6. 6

    Jupiter’s Great Red Spot has shrunk from about 37,000 kilometers in the 1800s to about 16,350 kilometers as of April, while winds appear not to have slowed as much.

  7. 7

    Juno’s close flybys and high-cadence imaging are linking structural changes—like increased turbulence—to possible mechanisms behind the Great Red Spot’s evolution.

Highlights

Jupiter’s Great Red Spot spans roughly 16,350 kilometers as of April, down from about 37,000 kilometers in the 1800s, while wind speeds may remain high.
Gas giant storms are frequently anti-cyclonic high-pressure systems powered by internal heat from gravitational contraction, not ocean-driven convection.
JunoCam imagery shows a shift from long streaks to smaller eddies inside the Great Red Spot, pointing to a move toward turbulent flow.
Turbulence can function like friction, potentially draining energy from the vortex’s bulk rotation and contributing to shrinking and circularization.

Topics

  • Gas Giant Storms
  • Jupiter Great Red Spot
  • Hurricane Convection
  • Coriolis Rotation
  • NASA Juno Mission

Mentioned