Get AI summaries of any video or article — Sign up free
Manifolds 7 | Continuity [dark version] thumbnail

Manifolds 7 | Continuity [dark version]

5 min read

Based on The Bright Side of Mathematics's video on YouTube. If you like this content, support the original creators by watching, liking and subscribing to their content.

TL;DR

Continuity between topological spaces is defined by open sets: F is continuous iff F^{-1}(U) is open in X for every open U in Y.

Briefing

Continuity in topology is defined purely through open sets: a function between topological spaces is continuous exactly when the pre-image of every open set is open. That single rule replaces the familiar ε–δ and sequence-based definitions from real analysis, because topological spaces may lack a metric for measuring “closeness.” Concretely, if there is a map F from a space X with topology TX to a space Y with topology TY, then continuity means that for every open set U in TY, the set F^{-1}(U) must belong to TX. In this framework, “points near each other” is translated into “open sets pull back to open sets,” so the topology itself carries the notion of neighborhood.

The same open-set criterion also clarifies what it means for a map to preserve topological structure in both directions. A homeomorphism is a bijection F: X → Y whose forward map is continuous and whose inverse F^{-1}: Y → X is also continuous. When such a map exists, the spaces are topologically the same: they may look different, but their open-set structure—and therefore their continuity properties—match.

Several examples show how the definition behaves at the extremes. With the indiscrete topology on Y (only ∅ and Y are open), every function F: X → Y is automatically continuous, because the only open sets to check have pre-images that are either empty or all of X. With the discrete topology on X (every subset is open), every function from X to any Y is also continuous, since pre-images of open sets in Y are always open in X. These cases highlight that continuity depends on the chosen topologies, not just on the underlying sets.

A more structural example comes from quotient spaces. Start with a topological space X and an equivalence relation ~ on it. The quotient space Y is formed by collapsing points in the same equivalence class, and its topology is defined so that the canonical projection q: X → Y is continuous. In other words, the quotient topology is engineered precisely to make q continuous.

The transcript then revisits continuity through sequences, connecting topology back to analysis. A function is sequentially continuous if whenever a sequence (x_n) converges to x in X, the sequence of images (F(x_n)) converges to F(x) in Y—so limits can be “pulled through” the function. In general topological spaces, sequential continuity does not always match open-set continuity; however, open-set continuity is stronger, implying sequential continuity. For metric spaces—and more broadly for first countable spaces—the two notions become equivalent, and the same equivalence holds for second countable spaces as well. That equivalence is positioned as a useful tool for later work, before the discussion pivots to compactness in the next installment.

Cornell Notes

Continuity in topology is defined using open sets: a map F: (X, TX) → (Y, TY) is continuous exactly when for every open set U in TY, the pre-image F^{-1}(U) is open in TX. This open-set definition generalizes the ε–δ and sequence ideas from real analysis to settings without metrics. A homeomorphism is a bijective continuous map whose inverse is also continuous, meaning the topological structure is preserved in both directions. Sequential continuity uses sequences instead: if x_n → x, then F(x_n) → F(x). Open-set continuity always implies sequential continuity, and the two coincide in metric spaces and in first countable (hence also second countable) spaces.

How does the open-set definition of continuity work between two arbitrary topological spaces?

Given topologies TX on X and TY on Y, continuity of F: X → Y means: for every open set U ∈ TY, the pre-image F^{-1}(U) must be an open set in X, i.e., F^{-1}(U) ∈ TX. This criterion uses only the topology’s open sets, so it does not require a metric or an ε–δ notion of distance.

Why do the indiscrete and discrete topologies make continuity automatic?

With the indiscrete topology on Y, only ∅ and Y are open. For any function F: X → Y, the pre-image of ∅ is ∅ (open in any topology) and the pre-image of Y is X (also open in any topology). So the open-set condition is always satisfied. With the discrete topology on X, every subset of X is open, so any pre-image F^{-1}(U) of an open set U ⊆ Y is automatically open in X, again making every map continuous.

What extra requirements turn a continuous bijection into a homeomorphism?

A homeomorphism requires three things: F must be bijective, F must be continuous, and the inverse map F^{-1}: Y → X must also be continuous. The inverse continuity ensures that the open-set structure is preserved not just when mapping from X to Y, but also when mapping back from Y to X.

How does the quotient topology guarantee continuity of the canonical projection?

Given a topological space X and an equivalence relation ~, the quotient space collapses each equivalence class to a point. The quotient topology on Y is defined so that the canonical projection q: X → Y is continuous. Practically, this means open sets in Y are chosen exactly so that q^{-1}(open in Y) becomes open in X.

What is sequential continuity, and how does it relate to open-set continuity?

Sequential continuity means: whenever a sequence x_n converges to x in X, the sequence F(x_n) converges to F(x) in Y. Open-set continuity implies sequential continuity in general. The two notions become equivalent in metric spaces and in first countable spaces; since second countable spaces are a subset of first countable spaces, the equivalence also holds there.

Review Questions

  1. State the open-set criterion for continuity and describe what set must be open for each open U in the codomain.
  2. Give an example of a situation where every function is continuous due to a choice of topology, and explain why the pre-image condition becomes trivial.
  3. In what kinds of spaces do open-set continuity and sequential continuity coincide, and what does that allow one to do with limits?

Key Points

  1. 1

    Continuity between topological spaces is defined by open sets: F is continuous iff F^{-1}(U) is open in X for every open U in Y.

  2. 2

    Topological continuity does not require metrics; it replaces distance-based reasoning with open-set pullbacks.

  3. 3

    A homeomorphism is a bijection whose inverse is also continuous, so topological structure is preserved in both directions.

  4. 4

    With the indiscrete topology on the codomain, every map into it is continuous; with the discrete topology on the domain, every map out of it is continuous.

  5. 5

    Quotient spaces are built with a topology designed so the canonical projection q: X → Y is continuous.

  6. 6

    Sequential continuity uses convergent sequences: x_n → x implies F(x_n) → F(x); open-set continuity always implies sequential continuity.

  7. 7

    Open-set and sequential continuity match in metric spaces and in first countable (therefore also second countable) spaces.

Highlights

Continuity in topology is exactly the rule: pre-images of open sets must be open.
Indiscrete codomains and discrete domains make continuity automatic for all functions.
Homeomorphisms preserve topological structure because both the map and its inverse are continuous.
Sequential continuity can fail to match open-set continuity in general, but it agrees in metric and first countable spaces.
Quotient topologies are defined to force the canonical projection to be continuous.

Topics