Get AI summaries of any video or article — Sign up free
Advice for Creative Writing Students thumbnail

Advice for Creative Writing Students

ShaelinWrites·
5 min read

Based on ShaelinWrites's video on YouTube. If you like this content, support the original creators by watching, liking and subscribing to their content.

TL;DR

Treat workshop assignments as passion projects when possible, because weekly deadlines make “separate obligation” writing less sustainable.

Briefing

Creative writing degrees reward students most when assignments are treated like passion projects, not chores—because workshop-heavy coursework leaves little room to coast. Balancing required deadlines with personal creative goals can be tough at first, especially when early assignments don’t match a student’s interests. The practical fix is to find ways to care about what’s being assigned, even if that means temporarily shifting focus away from a novel or other long-term work. Over time, that approach tends to make the degree feel productive rather than draining, turning critique and workshop participation into real growth.

A second make-or-break factor is managing time around a workshop schedule that rarely pauses. Workshop classes run in small groups (often around 10–15 people), with recurring submission and detailed peer critique every week. Because the workload doesn’t stop, students benefit from understanding their own writing process and planning accordingly. If drafting comes faster than revising, earlier workshop dates can reduce last-minute pressure on the first draft while still protecting time for revision. Starting pieces early—especially during summer before a fall workshop—also reduces the stress of having to generate multiple stories on a tight semester timeline.

Beyond the craft and scheduling, the degree becomes far easier socially when students actively plug into the writing community. Involvement—attending readings, reaching out to peers, and seeking critique partners—turns classmates into friends and collaborators. For shy or introverted students, the advice is direct: make the first move. Simple invitations, like asking someone to hang out, attend an event, or exchange work, often get a yes. Building connections can also happen through cohort culture, including group chats and shared activities, which can accelerate trust and make workshops feel less isolating.

Students are also encouraged to treat submission and experimentation as part of the training, not as threats. Submitting short work helps normalize rejection and can build publication credits; in early years, targeting on-campus journals and university opportunities can be less competitive than major magazines. At the same time, writers shouldn’t lock themselves into one form too early. Trying screenwriting, poetry, or playwriting—even without prior interest—can reveal unexpected strengths and expand skills through “cross-training.”

Other guidance focuses on resilience and judgment. Students should give themselves permission not to connect with everyone, while still extracting at least one useful takeaway from each person’s feedback. They should also maintain an idea “reservoir,” such as keeping a story or collection of prompts in a drawer, to prevent burnout from turning into a total creative drought.

Finally, the degree’s practical realities matter: reliable printing is essential because workshop submissions can require many copies and large page counts, and printer failures can cost marks. On grading, students should learn when a grade feels genuinely unfair versus when it’s simply subjective art evaluation—pushing every dispute can create unnecessary stress. The overarching message is to follow assignment criteria while knowing when to push boundaries with the right professor, and to treat the whole experience as something worth enjoying: a rare, multi-year immersion in a craft built around people who care about the same work.

Cornell Notes

A writing degree works best when students convert required assignments into passion projects, because workshop schedules and deadlines reduce flexibility. Success also depends on knowing one’s drafting-versus-revising pace and starting pieces early—often during summer—so weekly critiques don’t become last-minute panic. Social engagement matters: attending events, reaching out for critique partners, and making the first move can turn a cohort into a supportive community. Students should submit work to build publication credits and tolerance for rejection, and stay open to trying unfamiliar forms (like screenwriting) to discover new strengths. Practical planning—especially reliable printing—and smart judgment about grades help prevent avoidable stress.

Why does turning assignments into passion projects matter more in a writing degree than in independent writing?

Workshop-based coursework forces students to write to deadlines and specific assignment criteria, which can feel restrictive compared with writing on one’s own. The transcript describes an early struggle: assignments didn’t match personal interests, so the degree felt less enjoyable and less rewarding. The turning point came when the student found ways to care about workshop projects overall, even if that meant temporarily pulling focus from a novel. The payoff was more learning and enjoyment because critique and revision became part of a larger creative investment rather than a separate obligation.

How can students plan for workshop workload if they know they draft faster than they revise?

Workshops typically involve small groups (about 10–15 people) and recurring submissions plus detailed peer critique every week. Since drafting and revising take different amounts of time, the transcript recommends scheduling workshop dates to match that reality: choose earlier dates to reduce pressure on drafting, while ensuring there’s enough time reserved for revision. It also emphasizes starting early—especially before a fall semester—so multiple stories don’t have to be produced under one tight deadline window.

What’s the best strategy for making friends and finding critique partners when writers are shy or introverted?

The advice is to take initiative rather than waiting to be pulled in. Simple invitations—like asking who wants to hang out, attend an event, or do workshop comments together—often get a yes. The transcript also notes that cohort closeness can be engineered through shared spaces like group chats and frequent social plans, which helps people bond quickly and find partners for critique.

How should students approach rejection and publication during a writing degree?

Submitting work is framed as training for both rejection and publication credits. In early years, the transcript recommends targeting opportunities within the university—such as campus journals—because they tend to be less competitive than larger magazines. As confidence grows after initial submissions, students can expand to wider outlets.

What does “be open to trying new things” look like in practice for creative writing students?

The transcript argues that writers can get stuck in habits and narrow expectations about what they like. It gives an example of taking screenwriting workshops despite starting with no interest in screenwriting, leading to enjoyment and learning even if it wasn’t a lifelong passion. The practical takeaway is to approach unfamiliar forms with enthusiasm for the skill-building, treating it like cross-training—because even disliked forms can teach useful craft lessons.

What practical steps can prevent avoidable workshop stress, especially around printing?

Workshop submissions can require many printed copies—one for every class member—and can involve large page counts. The transcript describes printer failures causing presentation problems and even lost marks when pages didn’t print correctly. The solution: buy or research a reliable, ink-efficient printer and plan printing early enough to avoid jams and cartridge surprises.

Review Questions

  1. Which strategies in the transcript help align workshop deadlines with a student’s personal creative priorities?
  2. How does the transcript distinguish between drafting speed and revision needs when planning workshop submissions?
  3. What criteria should guide whether a student challenges a grade versus letting it go?

Key Points

  1. 1

    Treat workshop assignments as passion projects when possible, because weekly deadlines make “separate obligation” writing less sustainable.

  2. 2

    Know whether drafting or revising takes longer, then schedule workshop dates and work backward to protect revision time.

  3. 3

    Start stories early—especially during summer before fall workshops—to avoid the stress of producing multiple pieces in one semester.

  4. 4

    Get involved in the local writing community and make the first social move to find friends and long-term critique partners.

  5. 5

    Submit short work early, especially to on-campus opportunities, to build publication credits and normalize rejection.

  6. 6

    Stay open to unfamiliar forms (screenwriting, poetry, plays) to expand skills and discover unexpected interests.

  7. 7

    Plan practical logistics like reliable printing and use discretion when deciding whether a grade is genuinely unfair or simply subjective.

Highlights

The degree becomes far more rewarding when students find ways to care about assigned workshop projects, not just their private novel ideas.
Workshop schedules rarely pause—weekly critique and consistent submissions mean students must plan around their own drafting-versus-revising pace.
Shy writers aren’t stuck: simple invitations (hang out, event, workshop comments, work exchange) can quickly turn classmates into critique partners.
Reliable printing isn’t a minor detail; printer jams or missing pages can directly cost marks on workshop presentation.
Students should challenge grades only when unfairness is clear, because art evaluation is inherently subjective.

Topics

  • Creative Writing Degrees
  • Workshop Strategy
  • Writing Community
  • Submission and Rejection
  • Time Management